Goats might be firefighters of the future By Joanna Dodder Nellans, The Daily Courier
Settler Valley Ranch goats chomp away at thick chaparral at the United Christian Youth Camp in Prescott.
Courtesy
Printable Version
E-mail this story
As more and more homes pop up in the Prescott region, public land managers and fire agencies always are on the lookout for new ways to keep down vegetation to control wildfires in developed areas.
Rod and Tanya Baker think they've found a great option with their goats, and they're already starting to convince local fire officials.
"I hope this will be a way to diversify how WUI (wildland-urban interface) areas deal with creating defensible space against fire," Tanya Baker said. "This is another tool for the toolbox."
Wildfire is the most common natural threat in the Prescott Basin.
"This is a natural form of fire abatement, so hopefully this will be something that all types of people - environmentalists, traditionalists - can like," Baker said.
Because of the proximity to homes, prescribed burning often is not an option for reducing overgrown vegetation in the WUI.
The goats don't create smoke like prescribed burns and don't make noise like chainsaws, Baker added.
She is working with the Prescott Area Wildland/Urban Interface Commission (PAWUIC) on a three-month pilot project to see whether the goats can be a cost-effective tool in the Prescott Basin.
The commission is paying for the experiment in the heart of Prescott at the United Christian Youth Camp, east of Hassayampa Lane.
"I'm really impressed with what is going on out there, and the potential benefits to the Prescott area," PAWUIC Chair Everett Warnock said.
About 70 South African female Boer meat goats, an all-around farm breed, are chomping away at thick brush surrounding the camp cabins.
"They've done a lot to get rid of ground fuels," observed Kris Mengarelli, who is in charge of facilities at the camp. Hundreds of campers have come through, and camp officials say they have heard no complaints about smell or anything.
Hassayampa Lane drivers might get a glimpse of the horned browsers standing on their hind legs and chowing on the chaparral.
After some pre-clearing by an Arizona Department of Corrections fuels management crew, the Bakers are erecting a series of electric fences to keep the goats off the road and the predators off the goats, despite the strong presence of coyotes.
The goats' next stop Thursday will be the City of Prescott's Community Nature Center Open Space Preserve off Williamson Valley Road.
"That's a real critical area because it's just south of the Yakashba Estates," Prescott Fire Chief Darrell Willis said.
The Bakers and their daughter Mikayla hope to make their Settler Valley Ranch in Dewey a full-time operation with the help of similar goat jobs in the future.
They all are natives to this area. Tanya grew up raising 4-H goats, cattle and sheep in Dewey. She also volunteers for PAWUIC, 4-H and the Farm Bureau.
So far, Tanya estimates the 70 goats eat through one acre of thick chaparral in about four days. The test plots will help determine how many goats to use and how long to keep them in an enclosure, said Bruce Olson, a PAWUIC technical advisor who works for the U.S. Bureau of Land Management.
Mikayla Baker is helping monitor what the goats eat as part of a home schooling science project while the family lives at the camp.
The goats don't compete with cattle for forage, said Dwayne Warrick, a local range management consultant who is helping set up the test plots. It is common to see goats and cattle side-by-side on Texas ranches, he said.
The goats can help convert invasive chaparral landscapes back to grass, added Rich Van Demark, a forester and PAWUIC member.
It can cost $500-$1,000/acre to use machinery and hand tools to cut back vegetation in the WUI, and officials will calculate the cost of the goats in this experiment.
PAWUIC members also want to see how the goats affect archaeological sites.
While the Prescott National Forest and other national forests in this area have found goats useful, the Forest Service would have to amend its agreement with the State Historic Preservation Office to use the goats in any widespread fashion because the agreement doesn't cover goats right now, said Ed Paul, fuels management official on the Prescott Forest. Otherwise, extensive archaeological survey costs could make the projects cost prohibitive.
PAWUIC sponsored a tour of the pilot project last week, and officials from government agencies throughout the region attended, as well as some homeowner association members looking for options.
They heard Kathy Voth talk about a previously successful experiment that she and others conducted on a National Guard camp in Utah.
That project worked so well that the National Guard bought her goats and still uses them, Voth said.
"You guys have given me a lot of hope," Voth told the Prescott crowd.
(To learn more about using goats for defensible space, see the Internet at
www.SettlerValleyRanch.com and livestockforlandscapes.com. The Bakers also are offering public tours; call 710-3700.)
Contact the reporter at jdodder@prescottaz.com
Posted: Saturday, November 15, 2008
Article comment by: No name provided
For many years I rode in the mountians of Southern California and it was not unusual to see goat hearders, the state hired them to clear the vegetation every year.
Posted: Saturday, November 15, 2008
Article comment by: Rancher up north
Makes perfect sense! My goats are asking where to apply! A guy in LA was recently in the news with 100 of his South African Boers. Goat herder and his wife, a vet, rented their 4-legged work crew for $3,000 and all the brush the goats could eat clearing a 2 1/2 acre hillside (45-degree slope) downtown lot. Electric fence used to protect the goats. Not bad pay for a guy for 10 days. Human workers and machinery would have cost around $7,500, taken longer, faced more challenges, wouldn't have been as environmentally friendly, and would have lacked the entertainment value for the downtown workers who got to watch the critters in action from their skyscraper windows and at lunch! Hard to believe there are folks in the world who've never seen a goat up close and personal, but some of those folks were so excited, they went home to get their human kids to take them to see Nature at work!
Posted: Saturday, November 15, 2008
Article comment by: American Citizen
Enough burning...goats, goats, and more goats !!!
Posted: Saturday, November 15, 2008
Article comment by: Rich
The PNF used goats to clear vegetation around Ponderosa Park a few years back and declared it a success. They have yet to use them again. They would rather spend more money on burns.