Plant Cabbage with Tomato or Garlic to Reduce Insect Pest Damage
Cabbage Farmers may as well plant either tomato or garlic around their cabbage crop to reduce damages caused by diamondback moth (DBM), Hellula, cutworms, and other harmful insect pests. This practice is called companion planting.
Lucrecia Cocson and Lagrimas Flojo, researchers of the Mariano Marcos State University [MMSU] in Batac City, Ilocos Norte, found in a three year study that companion planting with tomato or garlic results in higher marketable yields and, hence, higher net income from cabbage.
Conducted in the cool months of October to February from 2004 to 2007, the study found that companion planting with tomato and garlic minimized insect damage as well as produced higher cabbage yield, resulting in higher net income.
According to the researchers, companion planting is a technique of combining two or more crops with _ the main crop so that some cultural benefits, usually pest control and higher yields, could be derived. In their study, they observed tomato as the best companion crop of cabbage followed by garlic.
In effect, it is an alternative non-chemical pest control technique. Thus, it is environment friendly, spares farmers from the hazards of frequent pesticide exposure, and assures consumers of insecticide-free vegetables. Moreover, there is an added income from the companion plants. Unfortunately, many cabbage farmers still use chemical pesticides for insect control.
Cocson and Flojo said that companion planting is one approach in integrated pest management that manipulates the environment to take advantage of the insects’ dispersed activities and on their preference for one host over another. “This strategy attempts to divert the insects from the main crop by presenting to them a more favorable substitute or a crop that would be deterrent to them,” Cocson and Lagrimas added.
In addition to the reduction of pest problems, companion planting is a very effective way of increasing environmental health and productivity.
Results of the study showed that cabbage + tomato combination significantly reduced the damages caused by Hellula and DBM. On the other hand, the cabbage + garlic combination reduced cutworm damages.
Hellula is an insect that feeds on the growing point of cabbage shoots at the early vegetative or pre-heading stage of the plants. Its damages come in two ways: one, the crop does not produce any head at all; two, the plants may produce multiple small heads that are not marketable.
On the other hand, the DBM larvae are voracious feeders on cabbage heads. This insect may cause farmers to lose 80 to 100 percent of their expected yield if left uncontrolled.
In their study, Cocson and Flojo harvested a total cabbage head yield of 14.86 tons per hectare in the cabbage + garlic combination, and 13.86 tons per hectare in the cabbage + tomato combination. In contrast, cabbage applied with insecticide, which had no companion crop, yielded only 11.32 tons per hectare.
The cabbage + tomato combination had the highest percentage of marketable yield: 97.7 percent or 13.54 tons per hectare. In contrast, the cabbage + garlic combination had only about 85 percent marketable yield (12.58 tons per hectare), resulting in a difference of almost 1 ton per hectare. On the other hand, the cabbage monocrop had only 77 percent marketable yield (8.55 tons per hectare).
Translated into net income, the cabbage + tomato combination gave P284,560 per hectare, while the cabbage + garlic combination had only P251,190 per hectare. The net income from the cabbage monocrop (P113,570 per hectare) was not even half that from the cabbage + garlic combination.
What is it in tomato and garlic that makes them effective companion crops?
Cocson and Flojo said tomatoes contain a toxin known as tomatin, which makes the plant unpalatable. Tomatin repels the DBM larvae or caterpillars from chewing the cabbage leaves.
On the other hand, garlic contains an active ingredient known as allicin, a sulfur compound produced when the garlic clove and leaves are broken. This deters insects, birds, and worms from feeding on cabbage plants.
Although the two ladies also tested marigold and onion as companion crops, they observed that only tomato and garlic minimized the damage caused by insects. In tomato, marigold repels white flies and soil nematodes; in carrots, carrot fly; and in brassicas, deters spider mites and a range of beetles.
Cocson and Flojo said that although the use of companion crops does not totally control or eradicate insect pests, these provide a barrier through their aromatic leaves that deters or repels insects from attacking cabbage.
To enjoy the benefits from companion planting, farmers may as well select companion crops of cabbage with the following traits:
1. It should have repelling properties like strong aroma and unfavorable taste;
2. Its common pests must not be similar with those of cabbage;
3. It must not compete with the main crop for soil nutrients and space, and the two must benefit each other;
4. It must be early maturing.
At the same time, practice timely planting, weeding and timely harvesting.
The researchers recommend that a companion crop should be planted at least three weeks before transplanting cabbage. By then the companion crop has already produced enough leaves and could readily deter insects away from the newly transplanted cabbage.
Plant the companion crop around the cabbage crop, about 0.8 meters along the perimeter and 1 meter away from the main crop to avoid competition for soil nutrients and prevent shading.
Cabbage, on the other hand, must be transplanted in sunken beds (at the bottom of the furrows) at a distance of 40 cm x 40 cm. The furrows must be moist to facilitate transplanting. Water the newly transplanted seedlings along the furrows to establish good root contact with the soil.