Received: Monday, August 18, 2008, 2:33 PM
> Mr. Laquihon,
>
> I beg your indulgence. One of the recepients of your email
> with the scary
> subject CAE HITS MINDANAO - CONSUMER ALARMED! forwarded to
> me this email
> knowing that I am one of those sincerely helping and
> working to grow our yet
> very small goat industry. I am disappointed to read the
> email for the
> folowing reasons:
>
> 1. I cannot understand the motive of the email and I donnot
> want to hazard a
> guess; Your subject is scary, yet you proceed and say go
> ahead and drink
> goats milk.
>
> 2. Kinuskusan, Bansalan, Davao del Sur is not the whole of
> Mindanao;
>
> 3. If DA Region XI has tested MBLRC and found them to be
> CAE positive, they
> must have made the appropriate recommedation on what to do
> with the animals
> for MBLRC to comply;.
>
> 4. It is not true that most of the goats in the Visayas and
> Mindanao came
> from MBLRC. You have mentioned some of the names of goat
> importers and no
> less than 6000 breeder goats, mostly from Australia, have
> been imported into
> the country and not a single case of CAE has been reported.
>
> 5. I see copies of your email sent to print and broadcast
> media. Are you
> suggesting that the incident in MBLRC that happened many
> years ago be aired
> and printed so people will be scared to eat goats meat or
> drink goats milk?
> It could alltogether nip the bud of this slowly growing
> industry. I can see
> that you too are aware of the need for us to improve our
> goat stocks. So why
> alarm the people when you know it is bad for the industry?
> Think of how low
> our current per capita consumption is of goat meat at less
> than a quarter of
> a kilo. We need to increase our goat meat supply to provide
> our population a
> healthier meat alternative. You are not helping the
> industry with this kind
> of information dessimination.
>
> 6. The Livestock Development Council have recently
> formulated a Dairy Goat
> Development Plan which is due to be implemented soon.
> Let's help DA do their
> job.
>
> The BAI have been randomly testing goat farms in Luzon for
> CAE including
> mine, and not a single goat have tested positive. I know
> they are doing
> similar tests in the Visayas and Mindanao to ensure that we
> only raise CAE
> free animals. Let us help government do their job.
>
> Let's promote the goat.
>
> Ben A. Rara
> President,
> Federation of Goat and Sheep Producers Association of the
> Philippines, Inc.
>
>
>
>
>
> --- On Sun, 8/17/08, Janoz Laquihon
> <jxysl2000@yahoo.com> wrote:
>
> "Nakakatakot na pala uminom ng gatas ng kambing. May
> CAE daw!" said one goat
> milk consumer. Let me translate for the sake of
> non-Filipino reader - Its
> so frightening to drink goats milk! It has CAE!
>
>
>
> Theres nothing to be alarmed of! Pasteurized Goats milk is
> always good.
> According to the Washington Animal Disease Diagnostic
> Laboratory (WADDL) of
> the Washington State University "There is NO evidence
> that the CAE virus is
> transmissible to humans. However, there are other serious
> human pathogens
> which have been transmitted through raw milk."
> Further, pasteurizing milk
> can inactivate the CAE Virus.
>
>
>
>
>
> So what is CAE? CAE is an infection in goats that caused by
> a virus called
> Retroviridae and the sub-family Lentivirinae. It is also
> called Retrovirus
> or "big knee" which according to literature could
> decrease production up to
> 25%.
>
>
>
>
>
> In the recently concluded Goat Raisers Conference held in
> Davao , CAE was
> discussed. Al Hoopes, importer of 5 bucks from USA ,
> claimed that his bucks
> animals were CAE free based on the test results from USA .
> Nevertheless,
> upon arrival to Philippines , it was CAEV positive. There
> is now a question
> of integrity. Dr. Catbagan, Director of Bureau of Animal
> Industry (BAI)
> answered it by saying that Philippines government has the
> right and
> authority to check these animals.
>
>
>
>
>
> Indeed, the Philippine government has its authority. But
> is it capable of
> doing a quarantine measures? I wonder, if Bureau of
> Quarantine has
> facility to quarantine the animals coming in? or are they
> allowing the
> importer to bring in the animals to their farm first?
> This is a gray area
> here. Costly? Yes! But if the government is really keen on
> protecting its
> interest, then, the government should not allow animals to
> come in
> especially from USA . After all, we do not believe in the
> integrity of US
> Quarantine section!
>
>
>
>
>
> What are the implications?
>
>
>
>
>
> 1. Since the bucks were brought to Mindanao Baptist Rural
> Life Center
> Foundation Inc. based in Kinuskusan Bansalan, Davao del
> Sur, the center now
> is bombarded with humors that its herd was CAE infected.
>
>
>
>
>
> How does the CAE virus be transmitted anyway?
>
>
>
>
>
> The CAE virus is transmitted to kids via colostrum. It can
> also be
> transmitted through contaminated instruments (example
> syringes, milking
> machines, hand towels), open wounds, or mucus discharges.
>
>
>
>
>
> If these bucks were used by MBRLC to its existing herd,
> used contaminated
> instruments (syringes without sterilization and
> disinfection), then there
> are chances that the whole herd maybe infected. You think
> MBRLC will do
> that? For those of you who have visited and trained there,
> you do the
> reckoning.
>
>
>
>
>
> During the meeting of Goat Industry Development Council
> (GIC) of Region XI
> held at AJML Goat Farm in Davao on August 16, 2008, one
> member of the
> council asked Dr. Rafael Mercado, chief of the livestock
> division of the
> Department of Agriculture XI (DA), if he is advising them
> to stop looking
> and buying for a good breeding stocks, especially from
> MBRLC. Dr. Mercado
> replied "No, we are not saying that you stop buying…
> you can do it at your
> own risks". He added "so far we only have tested
> MBRLC and found to be CAEV
> positive... I believed on the results conducted by Dr.
> Luban..."
>
>
>
>
>
> The MBRLC is under the jurisdiction of the DA-XI through
> its livestock and
> quarantine divisions. If indeed the bucks are CAEV
> positive, the MBRLC has
> to do the right thing.
>
>
>
>
>
> I thought of having an independent or private laboratory
> for a third opinion
> but who would believe them anyway? We don't believe the
> USA results, how
> much more of an independent laboratory in Philippines .
> After all, the DA
> is still the authority!
>
>
>
>
>
> 2. Most of the stocks around Mindanao and Visayas came
> from MBRLC. If the
> herd of MBRLC is positive of CAE then chances are, most of
> the goats are CAE
> infected. According to Dr. Mercado, "We will try to
> look if MBRLC had spread
> the disease." These alarmed the goat raisers! Surely
> this doesn't affect
> MBRLC only but the Goat Raisers in Philippines that got
> stocks from MBRLC.
> Goat raisers now feared that they got CAE. It doesn't
> help the goat
> industry develop at all but rather it creates dilemma.
>
>
>
>
>
> Some point to ponder in - Since 1971, MBRLC raised goats
> with the help of
> Heifer Project International. There was no mention of this
> disease until
> there was report in 1998 by the Food and Fertilizer
> Technology Center (FFTC)
> for the Asian and Pacific Region based in Taiwan that the
> CAE disease was
> introduced to the Philippines through the importation of 54
> goats from the
> Texas, United States of America, yet it was not clear were
> these animals
> were brought to. Until the recent findings of DA on the 3
> bucks somewhat
> connotes that the whole herd of MBRLC were infected. What
> is the point? If
> you got stocks from MBRLC before the recent stocks arrived
> in MBRLC, I would
> believe that they are CAEV free. However, if you got
> stocks from MBRLC now,
> asks them if the have used the 3 bucks already. You can
> trace their records
> if you don't believe what they say in words.
>
>
>
>
>
> 3. Importation Risk! One goat raiser asked "is the
> disease carried by
> imported breeds?". Dr. Mercado says "yes...
> since we have not seen it in
> our native goats". Not until the report of FFTC.
>
>
>
>
>
>
> There are importers I personally know who gets stocks from
> USA and Australia
> . They are: Kettie Chua, Vice Governor Piñol, Miles
> Abello, Neo Abalos, and
> MBRLC. Are they banned of taken in good breeders from USA
> ? Australia ? or
> other countries? Should the government make an official
> pronouncement that
> we cannot import stocks from these countries?
>
>
>
>
>
> Or what if these people stops importation?
>
>
>
>
>
> Let me illustrate. If you are an importer, went to US,
> selected good stocks
> from best farms around, completed the papers, had the
> quarantine regulations
> completed, clearances, paid my stocks, and shipped the
> animals in. Upon
> arrival, you were told that your animals CAEV positive.
> What would you do?
> Burn the animals? Well, if you have the money to buy
> another shipment then
> do it. If you don't have enough money don't import!
> Sometimes Money talks!
>
>
>
>
>
>
> Whose lose is it after all? It's not the importers at
> all. It's the Goat
> industry!
>
>
>
>
>
> Why? We cannot improve our goat breeds.
>
>
>
>
>
> Among the 5 importers I knew, I only heard MBRLC to be CAEV
> positive. I
> don't know what are the reasons are, but I would believe
> these importers are
> also willing to have their previous herd tested for free.
>
>
>
>
>
> What if these private companies don't want to be tested
> at all! Testing
> will costs them about P300/blood sample collected. The
> government will not
> accredit their goat farm if they refuse to be tested. What
> are the laws,
> policies, or ordinances on these? I wish to know too.
>
>
>
>
>
> What would the government do? The Philippine government
> had allotted P3M
> for Visayas and Mindanao through Livestock Development
> Council. According
> to Dr. Mercado, who is now the in-charge of OPLAN CAE in
> Mindanao and
> Visayas, this money will be used CAEV testing and the
> testing will be free
> of charge until December 2008. He further stressed that
> they are now
> studying how to get a good samples and spread the resource
> so that it will
> be based on scientific methods. He told every goat raisers
> to submit their
> farm profile so that they can use this baseline data. How
> long would it
> take for the government to study how to get good
> representative samples for
> CAE testing? I do not know. Maybe 2 years or more! I
> believe Dr. Mercado
> would not take that long. As of today, its personnel just
> finished training
> in conducting the CAE test using cELISA test.
>
>
>
>
>
> P3M is not for the reagents alone but also for trainings
> and mobilization.
> This will be thinly spread in Visayas and Mindanao . This
> amount is not
> sufficient since goat population in Mindanao surely had
> increased. If this
> amount is enough to have scientific and significant
> results, I would commend
> the DA! If not, it's a waste of time and money! It's a
> shame! Let's wait
> and see!
>
>
>
>
>
> If I will be ask how would they use the P3M? My answer –
> Let the DA buy
> Bucks or Does that are CAE free outside the country! It
> might be more
> meaningful.
>
>
>
>
>
> Again there NO EVIDENCE THAT CAE is transmissible to
> Humans!
>
>
>
>
>
> Go get Goats milk! It is nutritious compared to other
> animal's milk!
>
>
>
>
>
> Keep on Goat Raisers! Don't be fooled of the political
> warfare in goat
> industry. Let's do what we can do today without
> waiting for them. After
> all, there were no clear intervention and development plan
> of the government
> offices on Dairy Goat Industry - they focused on Dairy
> Cattle. If there is
> one though, act now and show it to the goat raisers with
> sincerity.
>
>
>
> What are your thoughts on these? Don't hesitate to
> share. It will be most
> appreciated.
>
>
>
>
> --------------------------
> Janoz Xn Yesu S. Laquihon
> Contact: +639208688862
> Web :
www.laquihonandsons.blogspot.com